A Lengthy Exchange with Georgia State Senator Josh McKoon

If you follow me on Twitter, then you know that Georgia State Senator Josh McKoon and I have gone a few rounds on RFRA, gay rights, and various other social issues. He gained national attention over the last couple of years for his push to pass a RFRA law in Georgia. Josh is a bright, high profile attorney from Columbus,  Georgia and given that profile and his busy schedule, I am always appreciative of the opportunity to trade intellectual salvos with him. We disagree on nearly every social issue we discuss. I think it’s fair to say that Josh is very much influenced by his brand of conservative Catholicism and I of course am very much influenced by my humanism.

Our latest conversation was around anti-LGBT language that had been appended to an adoption bill. As of yesterday, Georgia Voice is reporting that:

That anti-LGBT amendment to a Georgia adoption bill might just be dead in the water. Senate Rules Committee Chairman Jeff Mullis (R-Chickamauga) announced that House Bill 159 would be sent back to the Judiciary Committee for more work because the bill had become too ‘extreme.’”

Essentially the amendment would let “faith-based” adoption agencies, many of which accept tax dollars, turn away gay couples who were looking to adopt a child. Josh is of course on the side of the faith-based agencies, seeing this refusal to provide a service, as a First Amendment right to free exercise of religion. I see this as people who provide a service, using religion as an excuse to discriminate against a specific group of tax-paying Georgians.

Here is our exchange. It’s fairly long and took place over the course of a couple of days as I stole a few moments to check my mobile from time to time, but I think the exchange was quite interesting. I welcome your feedback and as always, happy critical thinking!

https://twitter.com/RLBays/status/843554694953885697

https://twitter.com/RLBays/status/843566539072782336

https://twitter.com/RLBays/status/843571748280918016

https://twitter.com/RLBays/status/843572210916909057

https://twitter.com/RLBays/status/843653145381289984

Here comes a pivot.

https://twitter.com/RLBays/status/843792680857604097

Yeah I went there. My excuse was that I hadn’t had my second cup of coffee yet!

https://twitter.com/RLBays/status/843803598538596352

Here I was finally able to ask a question that started addressing the root cause:

https://twitter.com/RLBays/status/843814591943589888

Notice he did not answer the question:

https://twitter.com/RLBays/status/843818603673718784

https://twitter.com/RLBays/status/843819088228962304

https://twitter.com/RLBays/status/843820571569872896

https://twitter.com/RLBays/status/843823452322779137

Josh shifted his focus to another person and responded to him with the following. Allowing me one last question which of course went unanswered.

https://twitter.com/RLBays/status/843875396810694658

Primum non nocere.

 

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s